FAMILY REUNIFICATION AND THE TRANSNATIONAL FAMILY
개요
In an age of increased global flows and knowledge sharing across borders, is state migration policy restricting opportunities and causing harm by grounding people, often away from their families, to one particular state or region? Discussion of family reunification in countries of net immigration such as Canada, Australia, and the EU nations often pits state interests against individual rights, including the right to the family. But are states and transnational families necessarily at odds, and if so, then does this always need to be the case? This research paper first identifies a series of state goals which, at first glance, appear to be divergent from the mobility of families. However, the paper then describes opportunities to align these state interests with individual rights, notably the right to the family. The result is a 12-part framework, in table form, that for the first time analyzes and demonstrates how existing state goals – that are currently used to justify the restriction of family reunification – could in fact best be enhanced through an increase in family reunification, within a reimagined citizenship regime that gives freedom to and gains from transnational families’ agency and resilience.
목차
Chapter 1: Introduction 1
1.1 Research Question: Reimagining Family Reunification and Mobility 1
1.2 Terminology: Transnational Families and Reunification 2
1.3 Method, Sources, and Limitations 3
Ethics 5
1.4 Theoretical Framework: Rescaling and Re‐Siting Citizenship Debates 5
Chapter 2: State Concerns Regarding the Transnational Family: A Six‐Part Framework 13
2.1 Introduction 13
Part A1 A Strong State 14
A1.1 Sovereignty and International Law 15
A1.2 National Security and Border Control 16
A1.3 Demographic Priorities 16
A1.4 Citizenship 17
Part A2 The Welfare System 17
A2.1 Social Services 17
A2.2 Health 18
A2.3 Skills and Education 18
Part A3 Economic Gain 19
A3.1 Labour Market 20
A3.2 Economic Stability. 20
A3.3 Capital 21
Part A4 International Development 21
A4.1 Development Commitments 21
A4.2 Declining Humanitarian Agenda 22
Part A5 Integration 23
A5.1 Allegiance 23
A5.2 Spatial Integration and Separation 24
A5.3 Language 24
Part A6 Family Values 24
A6.1 Family Values 25
A6.2 Marriage 25
A6.3 “Bogus” Applicants 26
Are State Goals at Odds with Family Migration? 26
Chapter 3: Aligning the State with the Family: Opportunities in Agency and Resilience 28
3.1 Introduction . 28
Part B1 Global Realities and Strengthening States 28
B1.1 Stronger Global Ties 28
B1.2 Diplomatic Advantage 29
B1.3 Attract and Retain Leaders 30
B1.4 Citizenship for a Transnational World 30
Part B2 Supporting the State: Health, Wealth and Belonging 31
FAMILY REUNIFICATION AND THE TRANSNATIONAL FAMILY
B2.1 Improving Social Outcomes 31
B2.2 Better Health 31
B2.3 Unpaid (Family) Labour in Private Enterprises and Households 32
Part B3 The Social, Economic and Political Power of Diasporic Communities 32
B3.1 Economic Expansion 32
B3.2 Social / Educational / Technological Transfers 33
B3.3 Innovation, Productivity and Competitive Advantage 33
Part B4 Family Reunification and Development. 33
B4.1 Remittances 34
B4.2 Family Investment 34
Part B5 Identity and Belonging in a Transnational World 35
B5.1 New Modes of Belonging and Allegiance 35
B5.2 Increased Civic Participation and Belonging 36
B5.3 Cultural Flows and Mutually Shifting Attitudes 36
Part B6 Families Across Borders: New Modes of Togetherness. 36
B6.1 Family Values 37
B6.2 Marriage 37
B6.3 Increasing Legitimate Migration 37
Opportunities for the Transnational Family and the State 38
Chapter 4: Conclusion 39
4.1 Summary 39
4.2 Current Practice: States Choose Citizens 39
4.3 Future Practice: Citizens Choose States? 41
References 44
Appendix: Family Reunification and the Transnational Family: A 12‐Part Framework (Table) 54
In an age of increased global flows and knowledge sharing across borders, is state migration policy restricting opportunities and causing harm by grounding people, often away from their families, to one particular state or region? Discussion of family reunification in countries of net immigration such as Canada, Australia, and the EU nations often pits state interests against individual rights, including the right to the family. But are states and transnational families necessarily at odds, and if so, then does this always need to be the case? This research paper first identifies a series of state goals which, at first glance, appear to be divergent from the mobility of families. However, the paper then describes opportunities to align these state interests with individual rights, notably the right to the family. The result is a 12-part framework, in table form, that for the first time analyzes and demonstrates how existing state goals – that are currently used to justify the restriction of family reunification – could in fact best be enhanced through an increase in family reunification, within a reimagined citizenship regime that gives freedom to and gains from transnational families’ agency and resilience.
목차
Chapter 1: Introduction 1
1.1 Research Question: Reimagining Family Reunification and Mobility 1
1.2 Terminology: Transnational Families and Reunification 2
1.3 Method, Sources, and Limitations 3
Ethics 5
1.4 Theoretical Framework: Rescaling and Re‐Siting Citizenship Debates 5
Chapter 2: State Concerns Regarding the Transnational Family: A Six‐Part Framework 13
2.1 Introduction 13
Part A1 A Strong State 14
A1.1 Sovereignty and International Law 15
A1.2 National Security and Border Control 16
A1.3 Demographic Priorities 16
A1.4 Citizenship 17
Part A2 The Welfare System 17
A2.1 Social Services 17
A2.2 Health 18
A2.3 Skills and Education 18
Part A3 Economic Gain 19
A3.1 Labour Market 20
A3.2 Economic Stability. 20
A3.3 Capital 21
Part A4 International Development 21
A4.1 Development Commitments 21
A4.2 Declining Humanitarian Agenda 22
Part A5 Integration 23
A5.1 Allegiance 23
A5.2 Spatial Integration and Separation 24
A5.3 Language 24
Part A6 Family Values 24
A6.1 Family Values 25
A6.2 Marriage 25
A6.3 “Bogus” Applicants 26
Are State Goals at Odds with Family Migration? 26
Chapter 3: Aligning the State with the Family: Opportunities in Agency and Resilience 28
3.1 Introduction . 28
Part B1 Global Realities and Strengthening States 28
B1.1 Stronger Global Ties 28
B1.2 Diplomatic Advantage 29
B1.3 Attract and Retain Leaders 30
B1.4 Citizenship for a Transnational World 30
Part B2 Supporting the State: Health, Wealth and Belonging 31
FAMILY REUNIFICATION AND THE TRANSNATIONAL FAMILY
B2.1 Improving Social Outcomes 31
B2.2 Better Health 31
B2.3 Unpaid (Family) Labour in Private Enterprises and Households 32
Part B3 The Social, Economic and Political Power of Diasporic Communities 32
B3.1 Economic Expansion 32
B3.2 Social / Educational / Technological Transfers 33
B3.3 Innovation, Productivity and Competitive Advantage 33
Part B4 Family Reunification and Development. 33
B4.1 Remittances 34
B4.2 Family Investment 34
Part B5 Identity and Belonging in a Transnational World 35
B5.1 New Modes of Belonging and Allegiance 35
B5.2 Increased Civic Participation and Belonging 36
B5.3 Cultural Flows and Mutually Shifting Attitudes 36
Part B6 Families Across Borders: New Modes of Togetherness. 36
B6.1 Family Values 37
B6.2 Marriage 37
B6.3 Increasing Legitimate Migration 37
Opportunities for the Transnational Family and the State 38
Chapter 4: Conclusion 39
4.1 Summary 39
4.2 Current Practice: States Choose Citizens 39
4.3 Future Practice: Citizens Choose States? 41
References 44
Appendix: Family Reunification and the Transnational Family: A 12‐Part Framework (Table) 54